Header Ads

How do ATP players react in high stress situations?

It is almost impossible to follow tennis, particularly on social media, without seeing players being accused of choking. In just the last few days, over the course of the five sets of the US Open final between Dominic Thiem and Alexander Zverev, both players were accused of choking on the big stage. Indeed, if you believe social media, pretty much every time that a player loses serve or fails to break serve, they have 'choked'.



Obviously, that is nonsense, but the concept of choking in tennis is a very real phenomenon. An article by Karlene Sugarman, a sports psychology consultant describes it as stemming 'from your need for psychological safety. The more threatening a competitive event is to your psychological safety, the more stressful and disruptive the situation will seem'.


One would expect that different players react differently to stressful situations and potentially that the same players react differently to different types of stressful situation. Actually determining what is a stressful situation is not as easy as it sounds, but for the purposes of this, we will look at two different types of situation - serving to win a set and serving to stay in a set. Clearly, there are many other scenarios that could be looked at, but we need to start somewhere, so this is what I have settled on.


Methodology

The way that I will investigate how different players respond to these stressful situations is relatively simple. It is easy to get the percentage of occasions that a player successfully held serve when serving in these situation, so this gives us a starting point. However, simply looking at that percentage will not give us a clear indication of how they deal with pressure. Players like Isner and Raonic will always have a high hold percentage simply because of their serve, but that does not mean that they serve well under pressure. Similarly, if every time that you are serving for a set is against Novak Djokovic, you would expect to have a relatively low hold percentage as he is arguably the best returner in the history of tennis, so that does not really tell us anything.


To get a better indication, we need to calculate how likely a player is to win their service game in each situation. We can take the betting starting price to give us a good estimate of the chance of each player to hold serve at the start of the match. This is a good starting point, but it can be improved further. By the time that we get to one of our pressure situations, we have additional information as to how the two players are playing. If a player has held to love in every service game up to the point where they are serving for the set, we want to take this information into account. The predicted hold percentage for that player at the start of the match is almost certainly not the best estimate of his predicted hold percentage now - given his success on serve, we would want to increase this estimate. Similarly, if a player has been broken to love in every service game, we would probably want to decrease our current estimate.


I am not going to go into depth on how precisely we would update these estimates, but for each of our pressure situations, we can generate an estimate on how likely a player is to hold their serve given the progression of the match up until that stage.


Furthermore, at this stage, I am not going to distinguish between situations where players may have a double-break advantage or disadvantage. It is definitely something that is worth drilling down into in more detail at a later stage as having the additional cushion of an extra break certainly reduces the pressure on that particular game.


Serving for the set

Of our two stressful situations, this is probably the less stressful of the two. If you fail to serve out the set, you are still in the set and still have opportunities to win the set. However, we still see players often changing how they approach points in stressful situations. I have written in the past about how players often approach their first serve differently on break points, either serving more aggressively to try and increase their ace percentage or dialing back their serve to ensure that they have a better chance of landing their first serve.


Using data from the past 2 years on the ATP tour, we have a set of 79 players that have served for a set on at least 50 occasions. Unsurprisingly, Novak Djokovic is the player that has served for a set on the most occasions, followed by the new US Open champion Dominic Thiem, Daniil Medvedev, Stefanos Tsitsipas and Roger Federer. Now, let us have a quick look at which players hold their serve most often when serving for the set.


We can see that no player holds serve more regularly when serving for the set than Roger Federer, who holds serve a remarkable 97.4% of the time in this situation. The likes of Reilly Opelka, John Isner and Milos Raonic are also not surprising given they are three of the biggest servers in the game. So, this chart does not necessarily tell us that much. Now, let us look at which players have the biggest positive difference between their actual hold percentage and their expected hold percentage.


Once we control for expected hold, we can see some different names appear at the top of this list. Casper Ruud and Fabio Fognini are the two players that see the biggest increase in their serve hold percentage compared to expectation when serving for the match. Now let us look at the other end of the scale.


Here, we can see a number of players that have spent plenty of time near the top of the rankings that can struggle to successful serve out sets. Indeed, we saw Alexander Zverev unsuccessful attempt to serve for the US Open title in the 5th set on Sunday night, so maybe we should not be surprised that he was unsuccessful, given his clear under-performance in far less stressful scenarios. Similarly, I imagine few regular tennis watchers will be that surprised at the appearance of the French trio of Gilles Simon, Benoit Paire and Pierre-Hugues Herbert in this list.

Serving to stay in the set

Attempting to stay in a set is arguably a more stressful scenario than serving for the set given that you do not have a chance to rectify the situation in the set if you fail. Based on the hypothesis that players struggle more in higher pressure situations, we would expect to see more players under-performing expectations in this scenario.


However, let us first look at those players that actually seem to thrive under the pressure of serving to stay in the set.



Interestingly, none of the top 10 players in over-performance here appeared in the top 10 of over-performance when serving for the set. It raises some interesting questions about whether players are mentally strong or weak in general or whether the personalities and mental approach of players mean that they feel different types of pressure in different ways. Let us now look at the biggest under-performers in this situation.


As we hypothesized, the drop-off in actual hold percentages when serving to stay in the set are significantly larger than for serving for the set.

This does not make good reading for Kei Nishikori. When serving to stay in a set, he managed to hold serve just 57.4% of the time compared to an expected hold percentage of 80.0%. He also appeared toward the bottom of the serving for the set numbers, which suggests that he really does struggle with his serve when the pressure is on. Precisely how this manifests itself is potentially something to look at elsewhere - does he struggle to get his serves in or does he change how he plays in the rallies themselves?

Fabio Fognini is an interesting one having been one of the biggest over-performers when serving for the set. Clearly he reacts to the different types of stress in very different ways. Alexander Zverev and Benoit Paire also appear in the bottom 10 of both charts.

The final player to note in this chart is the world number one, Novak Djokovic. While he tends to serve to stay in sets on fewer occasions than most players due to his general quality, he does tend to under-perform in these situations.

15 comments:

  1. Great article! We will be linking to this great article on our website. Keep up the good writing.
    دانلود کتاب اقتصاد خرد محسن نظری pdf

    ReplyDelete
  2. เดิมพันออนไลน์ สมัครวันนี้รับสิทธิพิเศษต่างๆมากมาย

    ฟรี โบนัส 50% ทำอย่างไร กับโปรโมชั่นพิเศษต่างๆมากมายสำหรับสมาชิกทุกท่าน เราเป็นเว็บพนันบอล ที่ดีที่สุด ไม่ว่าจะเป็นโบนัสแรกเข้าทันที 50% ได้รับในการสมัครครั้งแรก และสิทธิในการเล่นเกมส์รับของรางวัลจาก UFABET มากมาย อาทิ สิทธิในการเล่นเกมส์วงล้อสะสมแต้ม สิทธิในการแลกของรางวัลพิเศษต่างๆ ที่เราจัดเตรียมไว้สำหรับสมาชิกทุกท่าน เป็นการคืนกำไรให้ในทุกครั้งเหนือกว่า พิเศษกว่า บริการด้วยระบบที่ท่านสามารถทำรายการได้ด้วยตนเอง ไม่ต้องแจ้งฝาก ไม่ต้องแจ้งเจ้าหน้าที่ ไม่ต้องส่งสลิป ระบบทำรายการใน 3 วินาที
    แทงบอลออนไลน์
    แทงบอลออนไลน์ UFABET จะได้ราคาน้ำมากกว่าที่อื่นแน่นนอน เมื่อเปรียบเทียบกับเจ้าอื่น เช่นที่อื่น น้ำ 1.90 ของเรา น้ำ 1.94 หรือมากกว่านี้แล้วแต่คู่ เราการันตีราคา 4 ตัง แทงบอล กับเรา เริ่มต้นขั้นต่ำเพียง 10 บาทเท่านั้น เพราะเว็บเราฝาก ไม่มีขั้นต่ำ ด้วยระบบอัตโนมัติไม่ต้องส่งสลิป บอลสเต็ปเริ่มต้นที่ 2 คู่ จ่ายสูงสุดต่อบิล 5 แสนบาท ถอนขั้นต่ำเพียง 100 บาท การันตีความมันคงทางการเงินมามากกว่า 5 ปี ที่เปิดให้บริการ มีถ่ายทอดสดฟุตบอลทุกคู่ให้ท่านได้รับชมกันแบบสดๆ ดีกว่า ครบกว่า ด้วยบริการของเราที่มีกีฬาให้เดิมพันมากมาย แทงบอล บาคาร่า บาสเกตบอล ไก่ชน มวยไทย เทนนิส และอีกมากมายที่รอให้ทุกท่านมาสัมผัสที่นี่ ufa

    ReplyDelete
  3. Online betting Apply today to receive many privileges.

    Free 50% bonus. How to do with various special promotions for all members? We are the best football betting site, with a 50% instant entry bonus received on the first application. And the right to play games, receive many rewards from UFABET, such as the right to play the wheel games, collect points The right to redeem special rewards That we have prepared for all members It is a return of profit every time, more than a special service with a system that you can do manually. No need to notify Do not notify the staff No need to send slip Transaction in 3 seconds
    Online football betting
    Football betting online UFABET will definitely get the price of water more than anywhere else. When compared with other companies such as other water 1.90 our water 1.94 or more, depending on the pair. We guarantee the price of 4 sets of football betting with us, starting with a minimum of only 10 baht, because our website has no minimum deposit with an automatic system, no slip. Football step starting from 2 pairs, maximum pay per bill 5 hundred thousand baht, minimum withdrawal of only 100 baht, guarantee that it remains financially for more than 5 years in service. All football matches are broadcast live for you to watch live better than complete with our service that offers many sports betting, football betting, baccarat, basketball, fighting cock, Muay Thai, tennis and many more that are waiting for everyone to experience here.ufabet

    ReplyDelete
  4. Your post has shared a lot of knowledge with us. Hope you can contribute more to the community. Wish you a happy and happy new year. Tài liệu lập trình nơi tổng hợp chia sẻ những kinh nghiệm, bài giảng kiến thức lập trình, Java, python...

    ReplyDelete
  5. Very interesting discussion glad that I came across such informative post. Keep up the good work friend. Glad to be part of your net community
    Cẩm nang du lịch 24h | Địa điểm du lịch ở Bình Dương | Kinh nghiệm du lịch Bình Liêu | Văn hóa ẩm thực Việt Nam

    ReplyDelete
  6. Thank you very much for your article. I keep track of your blog throughout.
    Tin tuc dien anh | Tin tuc phim han

    ReplyDelete
  7. Very interesting discussion glad that I came across such informative post. Keep up the good work friend. Glad to be part of your net community
    reviewdienthoai | Mẹo hay

    ReplyDelete
  8. Your article is so good. I have read a lot of interesting things from it. Please share more useful articles.
    Phát triển token ERC20
    Làm token ERC20

    ReplyDelete
  9. The Growth of Ufa Entertainment

    ufa

    On the off chance that you have ever thought to be beginning a general business, by then you will not have to look farther than the genuinely dazzling yet monster control of Ufa in this cycle. The party UFA specifies "Ungrounded Front"; this term identifies with the way that the plot doesn't have full control of the last business thing that it sends across the line. This can make offering such things to clients in different nations truly more gravely engineered; paying little notification to it will all around be radiated an impression of being stunning less stunning by checking the parts that make it so mixing a singing response from so extraordinary business visionaries. To have the decision to understand the basic expansions of Ufa for your own general strategies tries, you from the most blessed beginning stage ought to be made mindful of absolutely why it is so charming.ufa

    ReplyDelete

Powered by Blogger.